Buying

Should I buy my Naples home in a trust or LLC?

Answered by Jim Chambers, nearly 40 years in Naples real estate and a licensed Certified Building Contractor.

Short Answer

A land trust keeps your name off the public record, an LLC adds liability protection but no privacy. The two are often combined, and holding a primary residence in your own name may better protect the Florida homestead exemption. Structure it with a Florida attorney before you sign.

For a six- or seven-figure purchase, how you take title matters. A Florida land trust keeps the owner's name off the county public record through a trustee, which is why many Naples buyers use it for privacy. A Florida LLC gives liability protection and charging-order protection, but Florida law puts the company's managers and members on the public Sunbiz record, so it offers little privacy on its own. The two are often combined, a land trust holding title with an LLC as the beneficiary, to get both.

The Privacy Play

High-value buyers sometimes want their name off the recorded deed to keep the purchase and the price out of public view. A Florida land trust, authorized under Florida Statute 689.071, holds the property in the trustee's name, and the beneficial interest is personal property rather than a recorded real-estate interest. That is the structure that actually delivers the privacy. It is worth noting that cash purchases into a trust can now trigger a FinCEN real-estate reporting filing, so the details should be handled by a professional.

The Liability Play

An LLC protects your personal assets from liabilities tied to the property, and under Florida law a creditor of an LLC member generally gets a charging order rather than a direct claim on the real estate. But an LLC alone does not give privacy, because the members are on the public record. For a Naples rental or investment property, an LLC is a common and sensible choice. For a primary residence, the calculus is different.

The Homestead Tradeoff

The Florida homestead exemption is the single strongest asset-protection and property-tax tool in the state, and it generally requires the property to be titled in an individual's name. Move a primary residence into an LLC and you can forfeit the homestead protection and the property tax cap. Many affluent Naples buyers keep their true primary residence in their own name, and use a trust or LLC for the properties that are not their homestead.

Financing and Due-on-Sale

One more practical point: most residential mortgages contain a due-on-sale clause, so deeding a mortgaged home into an LLC or a trust without the lender's approval can trigger acceleration of the loan. A land trust is sometimes structured to allow conventional financing where an LLC cannot. Before you transfer or buy into any entity, confirm with the lender, your title company, and your attorney.

Get It Structured Before You Sign

This is genuinely a question for a licensed Florida attorney who works on Collier County transactions, and the decision should be made before you sign the contract, not after. I can walk you through the privacy, liability, and homestead tradeoffs, and I will always bring the right professionals into the room early.

Key Things to Remember

  • A Florida land trust gives privacy; an LLC gives liability protection; neither alone gives both.
  • A common structure is a land trust holding title with an LLC as beneficiary.
  • The homestead exemption generally requires an individual title; an LLC can forfeit it.
  • Due-on-sale clauses can complicate transferring a mortgaged home into an entity.
  • Structure ownership with a Florida attorney before you sign the contract.

Want the full walkthrough? Grab my free Buyer's Guide.

Get the Buyer's Guide

Have a Question About Your Situation?

Ask Jim directly and get a straight answer grounded in decades of building, development, and brokerage experience.